Police Department's Proffered Reason For Terminating Black Lesbian Officer Was Not Pretextual

This case involves a number of discrimination, hostile work environment, and retaliation claims brought by Tammy Walker, a black, lesbian former sergeant in the Holyoke Police Department.

Granting summary judgment for the City, the United States District Court found that poor job performance, proffered by the police department as a reason for Walker’s numerous suspensions and termination, was not pretext to cover up the department's real motive of race, gender, and/or sexual orientation in violation of Title VII. Moreover, the department's proffered reason was not pretext for retaliation for Walker’s protected activities.

Walker v. City of Holyoke

Read the case